The Mythology Of Chi – Asking For Evidence
Dr. Tom Morris is an expert in philosophy and religion. He got a Ph.D. in both at Yale University and he was a Professor of Philosophy at Notre Dame for 15 years.
In one of his books, Philosophy for Dummies, he writes about the power of belief and tells the story of when he bought a gas grill. The Sears delivery crew wouldn’t hook up the propane tank because of liability concerns. As Tom hooked it up, he held his breath so he wouldn’t breathe any propane fumes. After a minute he would walk away and breathe clean air, then go back to the grill. He accidentally took a few breaths while at the grill and almost got sick from the powerful smell of propane. The fumes began making him light-headed and he began feeling sick, and even when he hooked the tank up, he could still smell the gas.
He called Sears to report the problem. They asked, “Where did you fill up the tank?” He hadn’t filled up the tank, and didn’t realize that Sears delivers a new grill with an empty propane tank.
Tom’s family got a big kick out if this, and as a philosopher, it drove home the power of belief. He thought the gas was there, he could smell it and he felt ill. “The mind is a powerful thing,” he writes. “And false beliefs can have a big impact on us.”
And there you have the “science” of chi. People have a tendency to automatically believe a black belt or a chi “master” without questioning, and when they tell you that you will feel something, you are conditioned to feel it, and then you believe it’s real. It’s a gigantic leap of faith, and quite a leap of logic.
If you are lying in bed at night unable to sleep, do this experiment: close your eyes and pretend you are on a small raft on a lake. Within a few minutes, you’ll feel the gentle bobbing of the waves and it will feel as if you’re on a raft.
This doesn’t mean you’re really on a raft, but it does show that the mind is a powerful tool and you can feel anything you want. If a teacher tells you that you will feel tingling when you do a chi kung exercise, if you try hard enough you will indeed feel tingling.
That does not mean chi is real any more than it meant that you were on a raft while lying in bed.
In 2001, there had been several articles in national martial arts magazines showing “chi masters” knocking down their own students without touching them. I offered $5,000 to any chi “master” who could make me even wobble without touching me. Inside Kung-Fu put my offer on the front page of the magazine and I waited for a chi master to accept my challenge. It would only take them five minutes to earn $5,000 — all they had to do is knock me down without touching me, or just make me wobble.
No chi “masters” ever took me up on that offer. I contacted one by email — Richard Mooney, who had made a lot of money taking fees from gullible martial artists who thought they could learn the “No Touch Knockout.” Mooney did not like the fact that I didn’t believe he could do this, and I received insulting emails from him and a couple of his students.
Still, no “chi master” took me up on my offer. The reason–they understand that without a willing partner — without someone who played along with the gag — chi doesn’t work.
People say, “But Ken, chi has been around for thousands of years. What do you know?” I reply, “Astrology and witchcraft have been around for thousands of years. Some people believe each of them.”
Chi is a great mental visualization tool. You can use it when doing chi kung to relax the mind and get your mind off of distractions. You can use it as a mental visualization tool to align proper body mechanics in martial arts. But as far as science goes, it has never held up to real scrutiny, and no chi master has ever been able to duplicate his feats under double-blind conditions.
The Randi Foundation has one million dollars in escrow that they will give to someone who proves a miraculous claim. The Randi Foundation tested Richard Mooney to see if his claims were true, but they removed the ability to cheat by conducting the test in what are called “double-blind” conditions. In other words, the people he was trying to move did not know what he was trying to do so they could not play along.
More than a dozen people were put before him — one by one — and he failed to move any of them. It was a complete failure. And yet, people still are willing to believe and magazines will print fantastic stories. Tai Chi students and teachers will tell stories of the long-dead master who had amazing chi powers. And people will relate personal anecdotes about how a tai chi master or chi master touched them and it felt “like an electric shock” and knocked them back 10 or 20 feet.
There is nothing mystical about Tai Chi or other “internal” arts such as Hsing-I or Bagua. These are martial arts that rely on physical skills (not metaphysical).
There is nothing mystical about Chi Kung (qigong). It is a method of calming the mind and body to ease stress — nothing more.
Never automatically believe a miraculous claim made by someone who is making money off of that claim. Always look for the “trick,” because there is always a trick. And just because you feel something, make sure that feeling isn’t the result of your own expectations. It takes a lot of emotional and mental strength to overcome this very human tendency.
Chaucer wrote, “many have died from mere imagination.”
It’s a lot like an empty propane tank, if you believe the gas is there. And people will always believe if they choose to believe, no matter how flimsy the evidence and no matter who is making money off of their beliefs.
About the Author
Ken Gullette is a 36-year veteran of martial arts and tournament champion who owns an
online kung-fu school
, teaching members around the world. He teaches Chen Tai Chi, Hsing-I Chuan, and Baguazhang. He has studied with members of the Chen family, creators of Tai Chi, and their disciples. Sifu Gullette believes in teaching Tai Chi as it was intended–as a martial art.
Visit his blog
for news and interesting comments on the internal arts.
Emperor Chi feat. Saigon and Joell Ortiz (Black Spartans)
|
|
Bosch TAS1000UC Tassimo Single-Serve Coffee Brewer, Anthracite $100.00 Better brewing by design, Tassimo is a brewing system unlike any other. Remarkable in its ability to offer an exceptional combination of quality, convenience, consistency and versatility. Only Tassimo offers a choice of coffee, cappuccinos and lattes made.3.3 bars of pressure; LED user interface; height-adjustable cup stand; water-level indicator… |
|
|
Chicago Cutlery Walnut Tradition 14-Piece Block Set $34.96 A great gift for the newlywed or college graduate setting up their first apartment, especially if they’re lovers of steak or grilled meats, this 14-piece set contains the blades most commonly used in the everyday kitchen. It includes two three-inch paring knives for trimming, peeling, and dicing fruits and vegetables; a five-inch utility knife for cutting sandwiches and slicing meats; and a six-in… |
|
|
Chicago Cutlery Landmark 14-Piece Block Knife Set $97.97 * Professional high-carbon stainless steel forged blades with patented walnut handles. * Exclusive Taper Grind® edge technology. * High-carbon stainless steel. * Full metal tang provides added strength, balance, and control. * Forged bolster increases weight, balance and safety. Landmark® 14-pc Block Set includes: 3″ parer, 4-1/2″ utility, six fine edge stainless 4-1/4″ steak kn… |
|
|
The Man I Want to Be $4.00 With an ear toward the past and an eye on the future, Chris Young is quickly distinguishing himself as a newcomer who honors Country music’s best traditions while adding a fresh new chapter to the genre’s legacy. With his rich, warm baritone and penchant for writing relatable, slice-of-life songs, Young’s sophomore project showcases a new traditionalist poised to take his place among his musical h… |
|
|
Strapped $2.52 STRAPPED – DVD Movie… |
|
|
Black Power: Music of a Revolution $12.70 The late 1960s-early 1970s were a time of great change, musically and spiritually. Some of the greatest music ever written came to life in this era. At the same time, political speakers like Malcolm X, Huey Newton and Stokely Carmichael stepped forward to lead a generation. Two words sum up the movement: Black Power. This two-CD compilation culls the greatest hits of that era, bringing together bo… |
|
|
Mr & Mrs Loving [VHS] $9.98 … |
|
|
China Rising: The Epic History of 20th Century China (3 VHS Boxed Set) $17.32 For seventy years, the “bamboo curtain” has protected China from the prying eyes of the West. Now, for the first time, Western filmmakers have been allowed inside the world’s most enigmatic country to reveal its forbidden history. From the romance of 1920′s Shanghai to Mao’s bloodthirsty Cultural Revolution, from the age of warlords and Japanese invaders to the era of the Avon lady, CHINA RI… |
|
|
Cosmic Slop [VHS] $14.95 … |
|
|
NEW DRILL BIT SET – 16 piece HOLE SAW KIT – 3/4 to 5 $6.02 BRAND NEW – 16 Piece Hole Saw Kit includes 3/8″ shank adaptor and 1/4″ shank adaptor!! Heat treated carbon steel is made for drilling WOOD! 2 Mandrel pieces Cut perfect circles with these tools! 1 Hex key wrench and 1 installation plate Saw sizes: 3/4″, 7/8″, 1 1/8″, 1 1/4″, 1 1/2″, 1 3/4″, 2″, 2 1/2″, 3″, 3 1/2″, 4″, and 5″ … |
|
|
CHI Air Black Compact Ceramic 0.75-inch Mini Flat Iron $49.95 Color: BlackPlate size: 0.75 inch Materials: Ceramic, power cord |
|
|
CHI Air Tech Black 0.875 Inch Variable Heat Tourmaline Ceramic Flat Iron $69.95 Produces an exceptionally high amount of negative ions Far infrared reduces static electricity Flexible 9-foot swivel cord |
|
|
CHI Air Onyx Black Air Expert Ceramic Hair Dryer $108.99 This CHI Air Expert Ceramic hair dryer will smooth and silken your hair. Rid your tresses of frizz and get the best results from your hair styling with this powerful ionic hair dryer. |
|
|
Farouk CHI Micro Chi Flat Iron (Mini-Size) $51.99 At only half the size of the original, the Micro CHI flat iron is your perfect traveling companion. The Farouk Micro CHI flat iron gives you all the benefits you expect from the full-size CHI flat iron. |
|
|
Porcelain 14-inch Solid Black Tung Chi Vase (China) $59.99 This unique and elegant vase offers with a wide opening for displaying a large bouquet of flowers. With an overall shape is similar to a decorative jar, this Tung Chi vase is handmade of porcelain with a solid black shine. |
|
|
CHI Air Expert Classic Variable Temperature Tourmaline Ceramic 1-inch Flat Iron $99.99 The CHI Air classic tourmaline ceramic flat iron utilizes the latest innovative technology combining tourmaline ceramic with even heat distribution. Hair is left smooth and silky with an unparalleled shine after using this ceramic flat iron. |
|
|
CHI Air Texture Tourmaline Ceramic 1-inch Curling Iron $59.99 The CHI Air Texture tourmaline ceramic curling iron utilizes the latest innovative technology combining tourmaline ceramic with even heat distribution. Hair is left smooth and silky with an unparalleled shine after using this ceramic curling iron. |
|
|
CHI Air Expert Slim Tourmaline Ceramic 0.5-inch Flat Iron $78.99 The CHI Air Expert slim tourmaline Ceramic mini styler utilizes the latest innovative technology combining tourmaline ceramic with even heat distribution. Hair is left smooth and silky with an unparalleled shine after using this ceramic flat iron. |
|
|
CHI Air Flash Tourmaline Ceramic 0.5-inch Mini Styler $47.04 The CHI Air Flash tourmaline Ceramic mini styler utilizes the latest innovative technology combining tourmaline ceramic with even heat distribution. Hair is left smooth and silky with an unparalleled shine after using this ceramic flat iron. |
|
|
Canvas Damask Double-sided Black and White Room Divider (China) $119.99 This versatile room divider features an elegant wallpaper pattern screen with fleur de lis medallions. Handmade of high-quality wood, this canvas screen will add an elegant touch to any room. |